If you’re looking to add a cardio machine to your workout routine, rowing machines and ellipticals are two of the most popular options. Both machines offer an excellent cardiovascular workout, but they have key differences that make each of them suitable for different fitness goals, preferences, and physical conditions. Choosing between a rowing machine and an elliptical depends on what you’re looking to achieve, your current fitness level, and how you like to exercise. Let’s break down the differences, benefits, and which one might be the best fit for you.
Understanding the Basics: Rowing Machines and Ellipticals
Rowing machines and ellipticals both provide effective full-body workouts, but the way they engage muscles and how they feel to use are quite distinct.
- Rowing Machine: A rowing machine mimics the action of rowing a boat. It is a seated exercise that requires you to push with your legs while pulling with your arms. This movement works your entire body, including your legs, back, core, and arms. Rowing machines are known for their ability to offer both a cardiovascular and a strength workout simultaneously.
- Elliptical: An elliptical machine, on the other hand, is a standing exercise where you move your legs in an elongated, circular motion while also using your arms to push and pull the machine’s handles. It provides a low-impact workout that primarily targets the legs, glutes, and arms, making it a great choice for improving cardiovascular fitness without putting undue stress on the joints.
Cardiovascular Benefits: Both Are Winners
Both rowing machines and ellipticals are great for improving cardiovascular fitness and boosting heart health. The choice really comes down to which feels more comfortable and enjoyable for you, as consistency is key to achieving cardiovascular benefits. Let’s take a closer look at the specific cardio advantages of each.
- Rowing Machine: Rowing machines are great for high-intensity interval training (HIIT) as well as steady-state cardio. Since the rowing action requires you to engage both the upper and lower body, your heart rate gets up quickly, and you can easily adjust the intensity of your workout by increasing your speed or resistance level.
- Elliptical: Ellipticals are ideal for those who prefer a consistent, steady pace over longer periods. The elliptical’s adjustable resistance allows you to increase intensity gradually, making it suitable for low-impact interval training as well. The elliptical is perfect for maintaining an elevated heart rate without placing too much strain on your body, making it suitable for beginners and people recovering from injuries.
Muscle Engagement: Full Body vs. Targeted Muscles
Both rowing machines and ellipticals provide full-body workouts, but they do so in slightly different ways. The type of muscles targeted can play a significant role in determining which machine is best suited to your fitness goals.
- Rowing Machine: Rowing is a full-body exercise that effectively engages your lower body, core, and upper body. During each stroke, your legs provide power for the push, your core stabilizes your body, and your back and arms complete the movement. This makes the rowing machine a fantastic option for those who want to build overall muscle strength while improving cardiovascular endurance.
- Elliptical: While the elliptical engages both the upper and lower body, the primary focus is on the legs, glutes, and calves. The handles allow you to engage your arms, but the motion is more about coordination rather than muscle strength. The elliptical is especially effective for toning the lower body and enhancing stamina. The workout is gentle on the joints, which is ideal for anyone with knee or hip problems.
Impact on Joints: Low-Impact Cardio Options
One of the reasons why rowing machines and ellipticals are so popular is their ability to offer low-impact cardiovascular workouts that are easy on the joints.
- Rowing Machine: Rowing is low-impact, but it does require good form to avoid injury. Since you are seated during rowing, it takes the pressure off your knees and hips, making it an excellent option for those who need a lower-impact exercise. However, improper rowing form can lead to back strain, so it’s important to learn the correct technique before diving in.
- Elliptical: Ellipticals are known for providing a smooth, joint-friendly workout. The elliptical motion mimics walking or running but without the hard impact, making it an ideal choice for individuals with knee, hip, or ankle concerns. The gentle gliding motion allows for a cardiovascular workout that reduces strain on the joints while still offering great calorie-burning benefits.
Calorie Burning Potential: Which One Burns More?
Calorie burn is a significant factor for many people when choosing a cardio machine, especially if weight loss is one of your goals. The calorie-burning potential of both machines depends on factors like workout intensity, duration, and individual body weight.
- Rowing Machine: Rowing is a calorie-torching exercise, especially when performed at a high intensity. A 30-minute vigorous rowing session can burn between 300-400 calories for an average person, depending on weight and intensity. The fact that rowing engages multiple muscle groups means that your body is working hard, resulting in significant calorie expenditure.
- Elliptical: The elliptical also has the potential for a high calorie burn, especially if you use a higher resistance level or increase the pace. A moderate 30-minute elliptical session can burn between 250-350 calories. Because it’s easier to maintain a consistent pace on an elliptical, it’s a great option for longer workouts that help burn calories over time.
Suitability for Different Fitness Levels
- Rowing Machine: Rowing machines can be used by beginners, but they do require some initial instruction to ensure proper form. The motion may feel unfamiliar at first, and mastering the coordination of the push and pull movement is key to getting an effective workout without injury. Once you get the hang of it, rowing is an excellent choice for people of all fitness levels, especially those looking to build strength and endurance simultaneously.
- Elliptical: Ellipticals are extremely beginner-friendly. The movement is simple, natural, and easy to master. You can easily adjust the resistance and incline to suit your fitness level, making it a great starting point for those new to exercise or for anyone looking for a straightforward cardio workout without a steep learning curve.
Which One is Right for You?
Choosing between a rowing machine and an elliptical depends largely on your personal fitness goals, preferences, and any physical limitations.
- Choose a Rowing Machine If: You’re looking for a full-body workout that incorporates both strength and cardio elements. If you enjoy dynamic exercises that challenge your upper and lower body simultaneously and want to maximize calorie burn, rowing could be the right choice. It’s also a good option if you’re interested in adding variety to your workout routine or engaging more muscles in each session.
- Choose an Elliptical If: You’re seeking a low-impact, user-friendly cardio workout that’s easy on the joints and focuses primarily on improving cardiovascular fitness. The elliptical is also ideal for beginners or those who are recovering from injuries, as the movement is intuitive and gentle on the body. If your primary focus is to improve lower body endurance and tone your legs and glutes, the elliptical is a great option.
Ultimately, both rowing machines and ellipticals are effective tools for improving cardiovascular fitness, burning calories, and boosting overall health. The best choice for you depends on what you enjoy and what aligns with your fitness goals. Whether you choose rowing, elliptical training, or even both, the most important thing is to stay consistent and keep moving.
Discussion about this post